School of thought
Pyrrhonism
Movement
Classification
- Period
- c. 330 BCE - 200 CE
- Regions
- europe
- Domains
- Epistemology
Overview
Pyrrhonism holds that for every argument an equally strong counter-argument can be found, and therefore the wise course is to suspend judgment (epoché) on all matters of belief. Paradoxically, this suspension brings the very tranquility (ataraxia) that dogmatic philosophers seek through their theories.
Key ideas
- Epoché: Suspension of judgment: when opposing arguments appear equally balanced, the Pyrrhonist neither affirms nor denies but suspends belief entirely.
- The Ten Modes: Aenesidemus cataloged ten types of disagreement (cultural, perceptual, circumstantial) that demonstrate the impossibility of reaching certain knowledge about how things really are.
- Ataraxia through Skepticism: Tranquility follows suspension of judgment as a shadow follows the body — when we stop insisting on dogmatic beliefs, anxiety dissolves.
Key figures
Pyrrho of Elis · Timon of Phlius · Sextus Empiricus · Aenesidemus
Methods used
Positions held
- Pyrrhonian Suspension
Question scope: The Possibility of Knowledge
- Epistemic Skepticism
Influenced by
- Atomism
Drew on the Atomist emphasis on the unreliability of the senses; Pyrrho was a pupil of the Democritean Anaxarchus.
Reacts to
Later connections
- British Empiricism Influenced by this tradition
The early-modern revival of Pyrrhonian skepticism (via Sextus) sharpened empiricism's doubts about how far the senses warrant knowledge, culminating in Hume's mitigated skepticism.
- Continental Rationalism Reacted to this tradition
Descartes' methodic doubt confronted the revived Pyrrhonian skepticism head-on, pushing doubt to its limit to reach an indubitable foundation that would answer it.
References
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Ancient Skepticism
- Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism I.8–10, 25–30
- Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism I.1–4
- Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers IX.61 (Pyrrho as pupil of the Democritean Anaxarchus)
- Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism I.1–4 (the skeptics against the dogmatists)
- Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism I.8–10
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Sextus Empiricus, §3.2
- Outlines of Pyrrhonism — Sextus Empiricus
- The Skeptic Way — Benson Mates