Epistemology

Science And Demarcation

What distinguishes scientific knowledge from metaphysics, ideology, speculation, or ordinary belief?

Positions

  1. Empiricism

    Scientific claims answer to observation and experience.

  2. Positivism

    Knowledge should be modeled on the methods and successes of the sciences.

  3. Logical Positivism

    Meaningful inquiry is disciplined by verification, logic, and the critique of metaphysics.

  4. Pragmatism

    Scientific concepts are tools within inquiry, tested by consequences and problem-solving power.

  5. Phil. of Science

    The issue is analyzed through explanation, confirmation, theory change, models, and scientific realism.

Discussion

Demarcation asks what makes science distinctive without turning science into a myth. The problem runs from empiricist trust in observation through positivist and logical-positivist programs to later philosophy of science.

The answer matters because modern philosophy often borrows authority from science while also questioning its limits.